Casey Key Florida Real Estate

Casey Key is a narrow, 8-mile long, residential island just off the coast of Nokomis, 15 miles south of Sarasota. This quiet, yet stunning island is home to just around 400 residents. There are many gorgeous waterfront homes on Casey Key, many with private beach access. 

View homes and condos for sale on Casey Key in Sarasota, Florida with RoseBay International Realty. Contact us if you have questions or would like to schedule a showing. 

Casey Key Florida Homes For Sale

Search with ease! Create an account to keep track of your favorite Florida homes. We'll send you email updates when similar properties match your criteria.

Browse Available Florida Real Estate By Island:
Anna Maria | Bird Key | Lido Key | Longboat Key | Manasota Key | Siesta Key | St. Armands Key

3752 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275

Nokomis, FL3752 Casey Key Road

Price$6,499,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS Number A4537866

  • Residential
  • Area Nokomis/North Venice
  • Mls Status Active
  • Square Feet 5,285
  • Bathroom 5

Exceptional opportunity for all boating enthusiasts with deeded beach access across the street! This extensively renovated and enhanced resort-like home provides an abundance of privacy on the exclusive barrier island of Casey Key. Located behind two gates, the property is fully fenced and secure. The main home is 3,522 square feet and the guest studio is 1,763 square feet. The main home features new wide plank oak floors, new tongue-and-groove ceilings, new composite kitchen countertops, appliances, baths, impact windows, standing seam metal roofs on all structures, geothermal HVAC systems and many more improvements too numerous to list. The covered boathouse features a 10,000-pound lift, kayak storage and dock, seawall and direct canal access to Little Sarasota Bay and the Intracoastal Waterway. The new custom-designed poolside pavilion is every Florida homeowner's dream: deep-water pool, spa, waterfall, fountains, a fire pit, grilling kitchen, lounge area and bar bring every amenity outdoors to be enjoyed year-round. Pick your own fresh fruit from the lemon, lime, avocado and mango trees, work out in the amazing exercise room or find the perfect place to read a book under the shade of the gazebo. Other features include a workshop, shed and outdoor covered storage. Deeded beach access is just across the street and a sandy shoreline along the Gulf of Mexico's turquoise water awaits your toes in the sand, long walks and sunsets are guaranteed almost every night.

Listed by PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 5.7% last updated on Jun 30, 2022
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Virtual TourSave FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

105 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275

MLS Number A4536711

  • Condo
  • Mls Status Active
  • Square Feet 1,170
  • Bathroom 2
  • High School Venice Senior High

A unique opportunity on Casey Key. Updated 3-bedroom/2-bath, income-producing, waterfront property with assigned boat slip. A perfect place for your get-away with the added luxury of gathering income while not in residence. On-site rental office, provided a gross income for 2021 of approximately $85,000. New AC and hot water tank installed 2016, new metal roof, new windows and sliders 2018, new living room furnishings, new dishwasher and range 2022. Comes turnkey-furnished. Gulf-to-bay community of 26 units, with subject property directly on the canal, beside the community pool.

Listed by PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 5.7% last updated on Jun 30, 2022
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Virtual TourSave FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

4004 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275

Nokomis, FL4004 Casey Key Road

Price$3,450,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS Number A4534806

  • Residential
  • Area Nokomis/North Venice
  • Mls Status Active
  • Square Feet 2,188
  • Bathroom 4

Nestled on one of Sarasota's most sumptuous barrier islands, this 2,188-square-foot home in Casey Key embodies the essence of summer in the Hamptons - with a front-row seat to the serene sunrises, stunning sunsets and sparkling waters along the Gulf of Mexico; you can have it all. Teamed with old-Florida charm and laid-back luxury, this three-bedroom, the three-and-a-half-bath residence boasts elegant renovations, stunning Gulf and bay views, along with a 10-foot deeded beachfront directly across the street from its doorstep. Renovated in 2013 by Jonas Yoder Custom Homes Construction, the open and airy interior features exposed beam ceilings complemented by timeless dark luxury vinyl flooring throughout most areas, and a wood-burning fireplace in the spacious great room. Completely upgraded, the gourmet chef's kitchen showcases pristine white cabinetry with plenty of storage space, a vibrant glass-tile backsplash and is fully equipped with stainless steel appliances and a double-door LG refrigerator with views of the bay from the kitchen window. Perfect for privacy when needed, each bedroom is en-suite and offers access to its own screened-in porch or patio and the expansive master suite highlights a spacious walk-in closet with plenty of space to retreat. Outside - an almost a half-acre opulent waterfront lifestyle awaits with gracious brick-paved and seashell-covered grounds, a seating area illuminated by tiki torches, spacious brick paver patio, two outdoor showers and a picturesque new wood dock with room for your boat overlooking the inter-coastal, mangroves and natural Floridian beauty plus plenty room to accommodate your future swimming pool. Additional high-quality improvements to this home include a new roof and HVAC system, new plumbing and electrical, new flooring throughout and all-new impact-resistant windows. Known for its magnificent custom homes and celebrity residents, Casey Key presents a poised beachside getaway along the sugar-sand shores, with modern elegance, breathtaking sunsets and bliss at every turn.

Listed by PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 5.7% last updated on Jun 30, 2022
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Virtual TourSave FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

4024 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275

Nokomis, FL4024 Casey Key Road

Price$3,190,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS Number O6025751

  • Residential
  • Area Nokomis/North Venice
  • Mls Status Active
  • Square Feet 4,481
  • Bathroom 4

4024 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis, FL 34275 Casey Key estate with unparalleled location, true Florida gem offering a secluded utopia while being close to culture of Venice and Sarasota areas. 180 views of little Sarasota Bay and a quiet deeded Gulf beach access right across the street where you can walk for miles. Waterfront views from the living room, dining room, family room and bar which overlooks the pool and spa with massive new epi wood deck below. Chosen by celebrities for both serenity and inspiration, welcome to the pinnacle of Florida living. You will find a perfect open floor plan, four bedrooms three/one bathroom pool home nestled between the faultless beaches of Casey Key and the intercoastal waterways. These views will truly take your breath away. The spacious master suite overlooks Blackburn Bay and boasts large walk in closets and a Jacuzzi garden tub. In addition, two guest bedrooms open onto a private balcony where you can relax and hear the surf. On ground floor is an oversized attached two car garage and there are two driveways with parking for up to 10 additional vehicles. Also on the ground level is a bonus mother-in-law's suite with the forth nonconforming bedroom, full bathroom, full kitchen and a separate entrance. There is an unheard of amazing storage space of over 3000 ft. also on the ground floor. The newly steel roofed boat house includes an aluminum lift for accommodation up to 16,000 pounds and they are two extra dock spaces for up to 60 foot vessels. This is deep sailboat water with access to the Gulf of Mexico. The living room has a double-sided stone fireplace, vaulted beam epi wood ceilings, travertine marble floors, and ceiling fans throughout. There is custom stonework on the bar to match the fireplace. The open custom kitchen is perfect for cooking and entertaining. Over $500,000 in renovations including in 2020 replumbing, three new air conditioning units, new pool deck done in Epi wood as well as new pool structure under pool deck, New pool refinishing and all new pool equipment. Also new steel roof in 2020 and remodel of the mother-in-law suite. In addition, in 2022 there was an addition put on the third bedroom with a walk-in closet.

Listed by BEYCOME OF FLORIDA LLC

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 5.7% last updated on Jun 30, 2022
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Virtual TourSave FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

1312 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275

Nokomis, FL1312 Casey Key Road

Price$20,000,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS Number A4533327

  • Residential
  • Area Nokomis/North Venice
  • Mls Status Active
  • Square Feet 11,785
  • Bathroom 8

The barrier island and enclave known as Casey Key offers some of the most exquisite residences along the Gulf Coast. Included in this portfolio of majestic gems includes Tweenwater, an estate aptly named as it rests between Sarasota's Blackburn Bay and the Gulf of Mexico. From the early stages of its conception to the meticulous level of construction and finishes, not one detail was overlooked in creating this one-of-a-kind property. The entryway features a custom staircase inspired by the Harvard Club in New York City, while the formal living room is reminiscent of a true British West Indies home. For ease of entertaining, the spacious kitchen boasts ample cabinetry and flows perfectly into the dining and family rooms. A carefully curated selection of antique and new elements combines to create this exceptional residence, blending modern luxury with old-world charm. Designed to take advantage of the cross winds from beach to bay, the screened terraces transition seamlessly from the interior to the outdoors. Past the resort-like setting and infinity-edge pool await bayside boating and kayak lifts, along with 100 feet of private beachfront to the west. Rest, relax and soak up the sun or savor the endless views from the shade of a chickee hut. Fitness enthusiasts will relish the exercise, sauna, kayak and bicycle rooms. Designed by Herscoe Hajjar Architects and built by The Aerial Companies, this magnificent masterpiece provides seclusion and privacy, breathtaking beauty and luxurious quality that leaves a lasting impression. Architecturally sound, the concrete pile structure, masonry walls, Hardie Plank cement board siding, hurricane-rated windows and doors and Kynar metal roof were constructed to withstand the tests of Mother Nature, while the solar panel system utilizes energy efficiency. For peace of mind, the entire property is automated with a Crestron smart home system and Lutron lighting, integrated security and a fire detection system. An oversized 8 car climate-controlled garage and whole-house generator complete this impeccable piece of paradise.

Listed by PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 5.7% last updated on Jun 30, 2022
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Virtual TourSave FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

412 S Casey Key Nokomis FL 34275

Nokomis, FL412 S Casey Key

Price$4,695,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS Number A4530819

  • Residential
  • Area Nokomis/North Venice
  • Mls Status Active
  • Square Feet 3,983
  • Bathroom 5

This exceptional waterfront setting is primed to gift you and yours cherished privacy, a panorama of picturesque views, and the "sheer" magic that occurs each day when a gorgeous sunset on the Gulf of Mexico is your most prominent neighbor. Be assured that great value is instantly added when the reality of this spectacular location ("location, location") is such a key foundation of your new home with your private Beach. This three-story, six-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bath home with 3,983 square feet of air-conditioned living space has been totally rebuilt. It is a split bedroom layout with separate in-law quarters on the first level. On the second level you will find an amazing Chef's kitchen with a Wolf 6 burner range, 2 burner grill, Sub Zero refrigerator, island, and glass front cabinets featuring LED Lights. There is wood flooring in the kitchen and the dining area. Travertine tile runs throughout the home. The open living room with a fireplace features incredible Gulf/Beach views just through the sliders. 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a laundry room, the Second Floor Balcony will just take your breath away as you can see the entire north end of the key. On the third level, wake up every morning to unique Gulf of Mexico views from your Master Suite. This level also includes a den/office/bonus room with views of the intercoastal and long bay view's complementing this rare find. The Master Bathroom features a stand-alone tub, large walk-in glass and tile shower, dual vanities, and solid wood cabinets with granite countertops. The entire home has had all windows replaced with Dade County hurricane specs as well as floor-to-ceiling sliders that open to a private balcony. Going down the path you will come across an incredible cabana. This cabana has built-in benches and tables, ceiling fans, curtains for privacy, and an outdoor shower. The lot is over 1/4 acre in size with a beachfront directly on the Gulf of Mexico. Enjoy the morning walks on the beach while hunting for shark teeth and bragging about the breathtaking sunsets with friends and family. 10 Minutes to Downtown Venice, boat storage within walking distance Look no further, this unique opportunity is an absolute must-see, must-do. Yes, A treasured lifestyle for you & yours, here and now!!

Listed by ACTION REALTY OF SARASOTA LLC

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 5.7% last updated on Jun 30, 2022
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Virtual TourSave FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

3999 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275

Nokomis, FL3999 Casey Key Road

Price$3,700,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS Number N6119928

  • Residential
  • Area Nokomis/North Venice
  • Mls Status Active
  • Square Feet 954
  • Bathroom 2

Welcome to Casey Key, one of the most exclusive barrier islands on the Florida Gulf Coast. This property offers a vintage "Old Florida" Cottage on just over a half an acre. Enjoy endless warm Gulf breezes by day and magnificent sunsets in the evening. The Casey Key residents own their beaches with no public access within miles of this property. Located just south of the historic Blackburn Point "swing bridge" offers easy on and off access to this magical island. Embrace the Island lifestyle, golf cart to nearby marinas, tiki bars, restaurants, grocery store and more. Casey Key is just a few minutes to Downtown Sarasota and St Armand's Circle as well as The Island of Venice to the south. Convenient and easy access to I75 and the nearby airports. The cottage is in good condition and would be a great beach house to enjoy the property until you were ready to build. Yes you have found paradise, Come Live on Vacation!

Listed by EXIT KING REALTY

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 5.7% last updated on Jun 30, 2022
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Virtual TourSave FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

1210 Casey Key Road Nokomis FL 34275

Nokomis, FL1210 Casey Key Road

Price$2,340,000

Est. Mortgage: $/month

MLS Number A4523245

  • Residential
  • Area Nokomis/North Venice
  • Mls Status Active
  • Square Feet 2,784
  • Bathroom 3

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. IT'S ALWAYS ALL ABOUT THE LOCATION! Casey Key is a very private narrow barrier island located just North of Venice FL and South of Siesta Key; it separates the intracostal waterway and the Gulf of Mexico. The Key is home to some of the most luxurious waterfront Estates and Mansions in the Sarasota area. This large ½ acre Bayfront lot is peacefully set back from any traffic on Casey Key Road. The dock is on the North side of the property on a canal protected from wind and waves. From the living room or the Bay-side deck, views of the intracoastal waterway and its many traveling boats and yachts are stunning. Take a short 100 yard stroll down your deeded beach easement, to the pristine sands of the Gulf of Mexico. The beach is very private, ideal for swimming, snorkeling, sunbathing, shark tooth hunting, or just viewing the beautiful sunsets. The main floor houses 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, the kitchen and the dining room. The first floor has one full bath and 3 rooms that can be used as bedrooms, playroom, den, etc. Other amenities include swimming pool, shuffle board court, elevator, and two single car garages. A new roof was installed in 2019 and the HVAC was recently refurbished. This property can be yours for a fraction of the cost of most other current Casey Key listings. Live in it "as is" or convert it to the home of your dreams located in paradise.

Listed by HOMELISTER,INC.

$
$
%
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 5.7% last updated on Jun 30, 2022
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Virtual TourSave FavoriteSchedule TourAsk A QuestionMore Details

Based on information submitted to StellarMLS as of July 3, 2022 . All data is obtained from various sources and has not been, and will not be, verified by broker or StellarMLS. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. NOTICE: Many homes contain recording devices, and buyers should be aware they may be recorded during a showing.